5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals rules House unconstitutionally passed $1.7 trillion 2022 spending bill using proxy voting.

5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals rules House unconstitutionally passed $1.7 trillion 2022 spending bill using proxy voting.

A federal appeals court ruled Friday that the House of Representatives violated the Constitution when it approved a $1.7 trillion appropriations bill in 2022 using a pandemic‑era procedure that let members vote by proxy instead of being present in the chamber.

The 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in New Orleans, split 9‑8, affirmed an injunction obtained by Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton, a Republican who is leaving office, that stops the enforcement of a provision of the bill that extended legal protections to pregnant workers.

The proxy‑voting system had been adopted in May 2020 by then‑Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi as an emergency response to the Covid‑19 pandemic. Republicans eliminated the rule after they gained control of the House in the November 2022 elections.

While the Republicans were still in the majority, the House employed the proxy mechanism to pass the spending measure that contained the contested Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, which President Joe Biden later signed into law. The legislation cleared the House on a 225‑201 vote, with 226 members casting their votes by proxy.

In its opinion, the 5th Circuit’s conservative majority held that the proxy rule ran afoul of the Constitution’s quorum requirement, which they interpreted as demanding that a majority of Representatives be physically present to enact legislation. “Although legislative bodies have broad latitude in setting procedural rules, the Quorum Clause imposes limits that cannot be overridden by internal rulings,” wrote Judge Cory Wilson, a Trump appointee.

The court’s decision addresses the manner in which the entire appropriations package was adopted, but the relief granted to Paxton’s office is limited. It bars the Department of Justice and the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission from applying the pregnant‑workers provision to Texas. Both the DOJ, which defended the law, and Paxton’s office declined to comment.

In a dissent, Judge James Graves, appointed by President Barack Obama, described the majority’s ruling as “illogical, inexplicable, and invalid.” He argued that the Constitution’s quorum clause does not impose a physical‑presence requirement and questioned why the court would deem the whole bill unconstitutional yet restrict its remedy to only a small portion of the multi‑trillion‑dollar legislation.

Post a Comment

Previous Post Zeniflix Post