
Washington — The Senate turned down a resolution passed by the House that sought to curb President Trump’s authority to conduct military action against Iran, losing the backing of several Republicans even as the party grapples with frustration over the conflict following its midterm defeats.
The measure was rejected by a vote of 48‑51. Only three Republicans — Senators Susan Collins of Maine, Lisa Murkowski of Alaska and Rand Paul of Kentucky — sided with every Democrat except Senator John Fetterman of Pennsylvania.
Thursday’s vote marked the first time either chamber has taken up the issue since the midterm elections, in which Republicans suffered sweeping losses. Voters identified the war with Iran and its impact on the economy as among their chief concerns.
Democratic Senator Tim Kaine of Virginia, who has repeatedly led efforts to limit the president’s actions on Iran, urged his Republican colleagues to support the resolution before the roll call. Speaking on the Senate floor, Kaine said, “It’s become apparent over the course of recent months that the war is unpopular, but its unpopularity was made absolutely manifestly clear in the election results from Nov. 3.” He added, “A historic repudiation of the party holding onto the White House, with much of that energy driven by Americans’ deep dissatisfaction with war, waged unilaterally by a president who said he would not, causing costs to dramatically rise on every American family. And so it is my hope, that in the aftermath of a clear message from the American public that they want us to stop this illegal, catastrophic war, the Senate will demonstrate that we’re listening.”
The resolution would have instructed the president to withdraw U.S. forces from hostilities with Iran, but its effect would have been largely symbolic. Under the War Powers Resolution of 1973, Congress can order a withdrawal through a concurrent resolution, yet administrations of both parties have contended that such a process is unconstitutional. The White House dismissed the measure’s validity after a similar proposal was adopted earlier in the summer.
Republican Senator Thom Tillis of North Carolina, who had voted for a prior effort, opposed the latest resolution. Tillis told CBS News, “This one doesn’t go to the president, so it’s just a statement from Congress. I’ve made that statement.” He continued, “I’m using other vehicles to try and figure out how to replenish supplies, but hold Hegseth accountable,” referring to Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin, and added, “I think I’ve been pretty clear that I think he’s a failure.”
In June, the Senate passed a resolution aimed at limiting the president’s actions on Iran, with four Republicans joining the majority of Democrats. The vote provoked a sharp reaction from President Trump, who criticized the GOP senators who supported the measure during a contentious lunch with Senate Republicans the following day. After that meeting, a subsequent attempt to restrict the president’s war powers fell short when key Republican senators changed their votes.
Since the conflict began in late February, Democrats have forced more than a dozen votes on war‑powers issues, most of which have failed. An effort in May advanced with the help of four Republicans and several absent GOP members, but it stalled after the president’s meeting with Republican leaders. In the run‑up to the midterms, the Senate considered another House‑adopted concurrent resolution; it narrowly missed passage despite a growing chorus of Republican opposition to the war.