
LONDON — A talk by Nathan Cofnas at Oriel College, Oxford, sparked a heated freedom‑of‑speech dispute on Tuesday after hundreds of demonstrators gathered outside the historic building. Cofnas, a scholar whose comments have been widely condemned for suggesting that very few Black people would occupy top positions in a merit‑based society, was invited to speak by a student group that supports the anti‑immigration Reform UK party.
Protesters arrived with signs reading “Far right off campus” and attempted to prevent attendees from entering the college. Inside, only about two dozen people listened to Cofnas, who spoke through a microphone while chants of “Shut him down” rang out beyond the walls. He argued that diversity, equity and inclusion initiatives are founded on a false premise and that the notion of equal potential across races is inaccurate, according to the student newspaper Cherwell.
More than 30,000 signatures were collected on an online petition, backed by the Stand Up to Racism campaign, urging the university not to give Cofnas a platform to claim that DEI harms higher education. The petition was met with support from some Oxford academics who praised Oriel for defending free expression.
Cofnas, whose invitation came from a society aligned with Reform UK, has previously claimed that in a true meritocracy Black individuals “would disappear from almost all high‑profile positions outside of sport and entertainment.” His remarks have drawn criticism from members of Parliament and from American poet‑turned‑student Amanda Gorman, who recorded an Instagram video saying the event sent “a very clear message to students of colour and faculty and staff that racism is welcome here.” Gorman challenged the organizers to give her, or another Oxford voice, a comparable stage to counter white‑supremacist ideas.
During the protest, activists placed a Ku Klux Klan hood and a placard reading “Racists welcome here” on the statue of 19th‑century imperialist Cecil Rhodes that stands on the college grounds. In the House of Commons, Labour MP Bell Ribeiro‑Addy condemned the university for “giving a platform to a eugenicist” in 2026, adding that “free speech sits alongside equality law, not above it, and little thought seems to have been given to Oxford’s Black students.”
Cofnas had been employed as a philosophy researcher at Cambridge University until 2024, when the university terminated his position after his critique of DEI programmes triggered protests. Earlier this year his profile rose again after he accused the late Cambridge professor Jason Arday – celebrated as the youngest Black professor in the university’s history – of plagiarism and of fabricating much of his personal narrative. Arday, 41, was found dead in his London flat in August following weeks of intense media scrutiny, prompting criticism of Cambridge for allegedly promoting him hastily to meet diversity goals and of news outlets for amplifying Cofnas’s allegations in what some described as a racially motivated public shaming.
Oriel College posted a statement on its website saying that allowing the event does not constitute an endorsement of the speaker’s views. The Oxford Universities’ Reform Society, which organised the talk, clarified that the decision to host Cofnas was made solely by its committee, not by the college or the wider university, and that the college was merely complying with free‑speech legislation. The society said its aim is to “rebalance” representation at Oxford and described Cofnas as “repeatedly victimised,” adding that it is committed to expanding participation in university life by removing systemic barriers for marginalized voices.
After the controversy, Cofnas took a postdoctoral position at Ghent University in Belgium, but his appointment was suspended amid the media storm surrounding the Arday case. In an August opinion piece for The Wall Street Journal, he claimed he had been wrongly labeled a racist and that his arguments were being misunderstood. He cited Harvard research to argue that, under a strictly colour‑blind admissions system, Black students would comprise only about 0.7 % of the undergraduate body, and that the current level of representation is sustained by affirmative‑action‑type policies. “There are many brilliant Black scholars,” he wrote, “but it is a difficult fact to face that in a truly colour‑blind system that didn’t take race into account, there would be a shocking lack of diversity in certain institutions.”
Cambridge University reported last year that an internal inquiry concluded that, although many found Cofnas’s views offensive, they did not violate the law nor breach university regulations intended to protect free speech.