Susan Smith will request parole again 32 years after drowning her sons in a South Carolina lake

Susan Smith will request parole again 32 years after drowning her sons in a South Carolina lake

COLUMBIA, S.C. — Susan Smith, the woman who drove her car into a lake in Union County more than three decades ago, killing her two young sons, will appear before a parole board again on Thursday.

Now 55, Smith was given a life sentence for the 1994 deaths of her 3‑year‑old son Michael and 14‑month‑old son Alex after a jury opted not to impose the death penalty. Under the parole statutes that were in effect at the time, she became eligible for release after serving 30 years and, if denied, could request another hearing every two years. The board turned down her request in 2024.

David Smith, the boys’ father, has said he will travel to Columbia early on Thursday to argue that his ex‑wife should stay behind bars. He is expected to wear a photograph of his children that was once circulated worldwide when Susan Smith claimed they had been kidnapped by a carjacker. The original prosecutors in the case will join him in the effort.

The parole hearing will be conducted virtually; Smith will participate via video link from prison. The seven‑member board must have at least two‑thirds of its members vote in favor for her to be released. Historically, the board has granted parole in only about four percent of cases, most of which involve non‑violent offenses, according to agency data.

Smith’s case remains one of the most infamous to come before the board. In 1994 she spent nine days insisting that a Black man had stolen her children from the bottom of John D. Long Lake, a claim that echoed long‑standing racist stereotypes of Black men as threats to white women and inflamed crime fears that were already prevalent in the 1990s and persist today.

Prosecutors have long maintained that Smith killed her sons because she believed they were the reason a wealthy son of the owner of the company where she worked ended an affair with her. Smith’s defense has repeatedly pointed to her mental health, arguing that she had originally intended to drive into the lake with the children but changed her mind at the last moment. Her attorney is likely to repeat the argument made at her first parole hearing—that she has no other criminal record and poses a minimal risk of reoffending.

At that earlier hearing, Smith told the board that God had forgiven her, asked for the same mercy, wept, described her actions as “horrible,” and said she would give anything to have her sons back. For nine days after the incident she made numerous, sometimes tearful, pleas for the safe return of Michael and Alex before eventually confessing to the crime.

Investigators later reconstructed the crash and determined that Smith’s Mazda sank in roughly six minutes. Water entered through the vehicle’s vents and rose steadily, while interior cameras captured the flood. The boys’ bodies were recovered still strapped in their car seats, hanging upside down, one small hand pressed against a window.

2 Comments

  1. I hope she stays in prison for the rest of her life

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree. What she did to those two innocent little boys was absolutely heartbreaking. They never got a second chance at life, and I believe she should spend the rest of hers in prison. Justice for Michael and Alex. 💔

      Delete
Previous Post Zeniflix Post